Book Review: “Erasing Hell” by Francis Chan & Preston Sprinkle

I recently finished reading the book “Erasing Hell” by Francis Chan and Preston Sprinkle.  Written as a response to Rob Bell’s “Love Wins”, Chan and Sprinkle honestly and personally wrestle with the rarely talked about doctrine of Hell.  In the introduction to the book Chan writes,

“I decided to write a book about hell.  And honestly–I’m scared to death.  I’m scared because so much is at stake.  Think about it.  If I say there is no hell, and it turns out that there is a hell, I may lead people into the very place I convinced them did not exist!  If I say there is a hell, and I’m wrong, I may persuade people to spend their lives frantcially warning loved ones about a terrifying place that isn’t real!  When it comes to hell, we can’t afford to be wrong.  This is not one of those doctrines where you can toss in your two cents, shrug your shoulders, and move on.  Too much is at stake.  Too many people are at stake.  And the Bible has too much to say” (pg. 14).

What follows is my own review of this new book.

THE STRENGTHS

This book has several strengths.  First of all, it wrestles with the doctrine of Hell from a biblical perspective.  What I appreciate about it is that Chan doesn’t try to sidestep the difficult questions raised by Rob Bell and others.  He understands that there are a lot of misconceptions and reservations about Hell, and he doesn’t shy away from addressing them.  Rather, he and Sprinkle look to scripture and try to understand what the Bible says about this doctrine and provide scriptural references within their proper context.

Second, the writers directly engage with many of the questions that Bell raises, but does not answer, in his own book.  Some of the questions that they tackle are:

  • Will everyone be saved?
  • Does God get what God wants?
  • Will there be a second chance at salvation after death?

Knowing that many people have the same questions, the authors try to address these questions with both sensitivity and with an eye toward what is actually revealed in God’s Word.

Finally, I appreciate the humility with which they write.  When “Love Wins” was published many evangelicals came out against the book, often misrepresenting or attacking Bell in the process.  The discussion around the topic of Heaven and Hell was, in a word, hellish.  Chan and Sprinkle take a very different approach.  First, they try to accurately represent Bell’s thinking.  Second, they take into account various Christian perspectives in their response and honestly admit where they personally land in the discussion.  Third, they try to support their views with a careful study of scripture itself.  Throughout, their tone is one of genuine dialogue and is born out of a desire to honestly understand the other.

THE WEAKNESSES

This being said, there are a couple of weaknesses with the book.  First, it is very contextual.  What I mean by this is that it is very obviously a response to Bell’s own book.  Because of this, those who have not read Love Wins” may feel a bit lost.  I also worry that this will hamper the ability of the book to speak to a wider Christian audience and create a more well-rounded view on the subject of Hell.

Second, the book doesn’t do a good job of giving the reader an understanding of where the doctrine of Hell fits in the overall scope of the Gospel.  I feel like this was a failing of Bell’s own writing, and I feel that it is also missing here.  This is not to say that Chan and Sprinkle don’t talk about the Gospel, but it is communicated in a more indirect way.  I worry about this because Chan and Sprinkle make a convincing argument that Hell does in fact exist, but fall short in talking about what is involved in helping us avoid Hell and enter into an eternal relationship with God.  For the seeker reading this book, it gives some answers about Hell without clearly point to The Answer:  Christ himself.

In addition, I don’t think you can talk about Hell without also addressing the nature of Heaven.  The two really do go together and I feel that talking about one without talking about the other can be very misleading and fails to root the importance of Heaven and Hell in the broader context of biblical theology.

Finally, there is little in regard to talking about how the doctrine of Hell informs our understanding of our present world and how this doctrine should shape Christian discipleship now.  While Chan frequently highlights that this doctrine is too important to get wrong, he does not go very far in talking about what its implications are for life today.

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS

Overall, I liked “Erasing Hell”.  As someone who has been following this debate, it is a helpful and humble contribution to the discussion which is firmly grounded in scripture.  While I feel it could have been better, I would recommend it to anyone who has also been following this discussion and wrestling with their own questions about Hell and its existence.

OVERALL RATING:  8.0 out of 10

Advertisements
Tagged , , , ,

7 thoughts on “Book Review: “Erasing Hell” by Francis Chan & Preston Sprinkle

  1. I’m not sure I’ll read either books, but I certainly appreciate your review. Keep up the good work!

  2. Benji Toh says:

    Thanks Nick! I recently read Love Wins and have been wrestling a lot with the issues it presents. I think I am going to pick this book up! Thanks!

    • Benji,
      Glad you found it helpful. If you decide to read “Erasing Hell”, let me know what you think. Also, I would recommend checking out Randy Alcorn’s “Heaven”. I’m reading it right now and it has really interesting.

      • Benji Toh says:

        Alright sweet thanks Nick I will let you know and I will look into Randy Alcorn’s book too. I have heard good things about him before especially in his writing about suffering.

  3. Ron Krumpos says:

    In 2011 world population will reach 7 billion (vs. 3 billion in 1960). There are now approximately 2.2 billion Christians. Chan and Sprinkle seem to be saying that 4.8 billion people may be facing eternal hell.

    Concepts of afterlife vary between religions and among divisions of each faith. Not all Christians agree on what happens after this life, nor do all Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, or other believers. Rebirth, resurrection, purgatory, universalism, and oblivion are other possibilities…none of which can be proven.

    Mystics of all faiths have more in common than the followers of their orthodox religions. True mystics realize that eternal life is here and now; it does not begin after mortal death. The age of Earth is said to be 4.5 billion years, of the Universe 13.7 billion, yet few humans live to be 100. This lifetime is a fleeting moment.

    Scriptures are subject to interpretation; people often choose what is most beneficial for them.

  4. Ivana Ajasin says:

    First of all I would like to say fantastic blog! I had a quick question which I’d like to ask if you do not mind. I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind before writing. I’ve had a hard time clearing my mind in getting my ideas out. I truly do enjoy writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are usually lost simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or tips? Cheers!

    • Ivana,
      It usually just takes a lot of time and thought. I end up deleting most of my original rough drafts just because, as I think about the topics, I realize that I’m not really communicating what I want. My average post takes about a week to a week and a half of reflection before I’ve written and published it in the way that I want. What I would say is to not give up. It is okay to stop writing and come back to the post later. One book that really helped me was “On Writing Well” by William Zinsser. I feel like I am still learning from that book and it is one that I read over and over again. Hope that helps.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: